Developer docs
API playgroundTry for free, no card

Search company profiles

Test Valley Borough Council

Full company profile

uuid00ypcgi

Namestring
Test Valley Borough Council
Legal namestring
Test Valley Borough Council
Company typeenum
Public
Founded yearstring
-
Descriptiontext

Test Valley Borough Council is a statutory UK local government authority serving the Test Valley borough in Hampshire, England, encompassing the towns of Andover and Romsey and surrounding villages. The council delivers a comprehensive portfolio of mandated public services to borough residents and businesses, including waste collection and recycling, street cleaning, planning and building control, housing and homelessness services, council tax and benefits administration, licensing and regulation, parking management, and community leisure facilities such as parks, allotments, and The Lights cultural venue.

The council's technology footprint is modest and typical of UK district councils. Its primary digital surface is the public-facing website at testvalley.gov.uk, supplemented by the My Test Valley online self-service portal (my.testvalley.gov.uk), through which residents can report issues, submit service requests, and transact 24/7. The website is partially WCAG 2.1 AA compliant with adjustable text-size and contrast settings. No proprietary platform, custom AI/ML system, or significant technology IP was identified in the source material. Outreach is conducted via Facebook, Twitter/X, a GovDelivery email newsletter, and community engagement initiatives such as Sparkle Days and the Love Where You Live environmental programme (with roughly 950 registered Community Litter Picker households).

The council's revenue model is consistent with UK local authority funding. It is primarily financed through council tax, retained business rates, and central government grants, with a supplemental fee stream from published annual fees and charges covering planning, parking, licensing, waste, and facility rentals. Service delivery spans two physical council offices (Andover headquarters at Beech Hurst and a Romsey office), the digital self-service portal, telephone and email contact centres, and field operations. The council is governed by elected councillors with operational oversight from a professional management team. The source material references an ongoing local government reorganisation initiative, indicating potential structural changes to the council's governance arrangements.

Short descriptiontext

Test Valley Borough Council is a statutory UK local government authority serving residents and businesses of the Test Valley borough in Hampshire. It delivers mandated services including waste management, planning, housing, parking, licensing, benefits administration, and community facilities.

Operating statusenum
Operating
Ownership categoryenum
Headcount rangeband
251–500
akta.pro rankint
HeadquartersAndover, United Kingdom
HQ citystring
Andover
HQ countrystring
United Kingdom
HQ regionstring
Europe
Markets served

Serves global market

Offices2 records

Each record includes

City, Country, Type, Description, Source

Keyword5 values
local government services, waste management services, planning and building control, council tax administration, parking and transport
Industry1 code
PRIMARYBPAIACAD
Municipal Tax & Revenue Administration (Local)
NAICS code3 codes
  • Administration of Environmental Quality Programs9241
  • Administration of Housing Programs, Urban Planning, and Community Development925
  • Administration of Housing Programs, Urban Planning, and Community Development9251
SIC code3 codes
  • Sanitary Services4950
  • Refuse Systems4953
  • Services-Social Services8300
Product category
Local Government Services
Marketing channels5 records

Each record includes

Title, Type, Stage, Description, Source

Distribution channels3 records

Each record includes

Title, Type, Scope, Target buyer, Description, Source

Cost components5 values
Personnel, Operations, Infrastructure, Technology or R&D, Others
Pricing details1 tier
1Fees and Charges 2026-27
ModelOtherBilling cadenceAnnual
Notes

Annual fees and charges approved by the Council published as downloadable PDF documents. Covers services including planning, parking, licensing, waste, and facilities.

testvalley.gov.uk
GTM typeB2C
B2C
Offering typeServices
Services
Core offering1 text field

Test Valley Borough Council is a statutory local government authority that delivers mandated public services to residents and businesses in the Test Valley area of Hampshire, England. Its core offerings include waste collection and recycling, planning and building control, housing services, council tax and benefits administration, parking management, licensing and regulation, street cleaning, and community leisure facilities. Services are funded through council tax, business rates, and central government grants, and are delivered through two council offices in Andover and Romsey, the public website, and the My Test Valley online self-service portal.

Differentiator
Functional benefit
Problem solved
Quantifiable outcome1 of 4 values shown
  • Community Litter Pickers programme: ~950 households registered throughout the borough
+3 more records
Product overview1 text field

Test Valley Borough Council provides a comprehensive portfolio of local government services to residents and businesses in the Test Valley area of Hampshire. The council operates as a service provider across multiple domains including waste management and recycling, parking and car parks, street cleaning, planning services, benefits administration, housing, licensing, and community leisure facilities. Services are delivered through a combination of physical locations (two council offices in Andover and Romsey), online self-service portals (My Test Valley), and direct service operations. The council's digital presence includes website-based information and transaction services, with some forms built and hosted through third-party software.

Product and service9 records
1Waste & Recycling Services
CategoryCore Council Service
Description

Municipal waste collection, recycling programs, household waste recycling centres, home composting support, and hazardous waste disposal services for residents within the Test Valley borough.

2Parking & Car Parks
CategoryCore Council Service
Description

Management of public car parks in Andover and Romsey, parking permits, penalty charge notices, RingGo mobile payment, electric vehicle charging, and Blue Badge concessions.

3Street Cleaning & Litter Services
CategoryCore Council Service
Description

Street sweeping, litter removal, leaf clearance, dog waste bin management, graffiti removal coordination, community litter picker programmes, and fly-tipping investigation and enforcement.

4Planning Services
CategoryCore Council Service
Description

Development management, planning policy, building control, heritage protection, archaeology reviews, and neighbourhood planning for the borough.

5Benefits & Council Tax
CategoryCore Council Service
Description

Administration of local council tax, housing benefits, business rates, and related financial services for residents and businesses.

6Housing Services
CategoryCore Council Service
Description

Affordable housing, housing applications, homelessness assistance, and private sector housing support.

7Licensing Services
CategoryCore Council Service
Description

Animal welfare licensing, zoo licensing, street trading consents, and other regulatory licensing under the Zoo Licensing Act 1981.

8Community & Leisure
CategoryCore Council Service
Description

Parks and green spaces, allotments, markets in Andover, The Lights venue, community safety initiatives, and antisocial behaviour coordination.

9Online Reporting & Self-Service Portal (My Test Valley)
CategoryDigital Service Platform
Description

Online portal for residents to report issues, access services, submit requests, and manage council-related transactions digitally.

Partnership6 partners
Strategic tierCoreTypeStrategic or Co-development Partner
Description

Hampshire County Council is a key partner responsible for Household Waste Recycling Centres (HWRCs), highways maintenance, on-street parking enforcement, and community transport (Connect) within the Test Valley area. The two councils collaborate on travel planning through My Journey Hampshire and share data for the National Fraud Initiative. HWRCs in Test Valley include Scott Close (Andover) and Casbrook/Bunny Lane (near Romsey).

Strategic tierMinorTypeStrategic or Co-development Partner
Description

The Lights is a cultural venue and arts centre in Andover that Test Valley Borough Council partners with for events programming. The council website links to The Lights event listings, indicating a collaborative relationship for cultural and community event promotion.

3Community Payback
Strategic tierMinorTypeStrategic or Co-development Partner
Description

Test Valley Borough Council works in partnership with Community Payback, a rehabilitative community service programme, to assist with litter picking, hedge cutting, re-painting, and repairs throughout the borough.

testvalley.gov.uk
Strategic tierCoreTypeStrategic or Co-development Partner
Description

Test Valley Borough Council participates in the Cabinet Office's National Fraud Initiative, a data matching exercise to assist in the prevention and detection of fraud. The council provides particular sets of data to the Minister for the Cabinet Office for matching under statutory authority (Part 6 of the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014).

5Project Integra
Strategic tierMinorTypeStrategic or Co-development Partner
Description

Project Integra is referenced as a partner for household waste recycling centre information, suggesting a waste management partnership among Hampshire local authorities coordinated through this initiative.

testvalley.gov.uk
Strategic tierMinorTypeChannel Partner/ Reseller/ Distributor
Description

My Journey Hampshire is a travel awareness campaign delivered by local councils including Test Valley Borough Council, with funding from the Department for Transport. It provides travel information and advice across the Hampshire area including walking, cycling, bus, train, and car travel options.

Recent move6 records

Each record includes

Date, Type, Title, Description, Source

Expansion highlight4 records

Each record includes

Type, Description

Peers10 records
TypeDirect peer
Description

Adjacent Hampshire district council serving a comparable mix of town and rural residents with the same statutory service portfolio; useful peer for benchmarking service quality and digital delivery.

2Chichester District Council
TypeDirect peer
Description

Another southern English district council with a comparable rural-urban mix and statutory service portfolio; useful peer for digital channel and community programme benchmarks.

3Project Integra
TypeOthers
Description

Hampshire-wide waste partnership of which Test Valley is a member; comparable as an ecosystem partner rather than a competitor, relevant for understanding waste service economics.

4New Forest District Council
TypeDirect peer
Description

Adjacent Hampshire district with similar semi-rural geography and resident base, delivering identical statutory functions; directly comparable on service scope and digital maturity.

TypeDirect peer
Description

Larger Hampshire neighbour providing the same statutory services, with overlapping residents and shared Hampshire-wide initiatives; a natural peer for operational comparison.

6Wiltshire Council
TypeBroad incumbent
Description

Unitary authority neighbouring Hampshire with overlapping residents in the Salisbury/Test Valley corridor; comparable on waste and planning but operating at a larger unit scale.

TypeBroad incumbent
Description

Upper-tier authority that delivers county-wide services (highways, HWRCs, on-street parking) overlapping with Test Valley's footprint. Direct strategic partner and the most operationally comparable peer.

TypeDirect peer
Description

Mid-sized southern English district council delivering the same statutory services with a comparable resident base; useful peer for benchmarking fees, charges, and digital portal uptake.

9Eastleigh Borough Council
TypeDirect peer
Description

Neighbouring Hampshire district council delivering the same statutory services (waste, planning, housing, licensing) to a similar suburban/semi-rural population. Closest like-for-like comparator.

TypeRegional player
Description

Parish-level council just across the Wiltshire border serving the Salisbury catchment that overlaps parts of Test Valley; comparable on community engagement and local service delivery.

Market position
Strengths4 records

Each record includes

Headline, Details, Source

Weaknesses4 records

Each record includes

Headline, Details, Source

Competitive moat2 records

Each record includes

Type, Details

Key risks4 records

Each record includes

Headline, Details, Source

Key highlights6 records

Each record includes

Headline, Details, Source

Customer concentration

Classification, Details

Segment1 record

Each record includes

Title, Type, Primary, Description, Pain point addressed, Use case, Source

Ideal customer profile2 records

Each record includes

Profile, Firmographic size, Sales motion, Sales cycle length, Buying structure, Purchase trigger, Buyer persona, Geography, Industry vertical, Primary use case, Description, Pain points, Evidence proof points, Target buyer

Technology focused
No
API detail
Has APIbool
No

Docs URL, Description

AI maturity
App detail

Has app

Core technology
Revenue estimate
Valuation estimate
Number of profiles
No data
No data
Funding overview

Funding stage, Last funding date, Total funding USD

Funding rounds

Each record includes

Round, Amount USD, Date, Pre money valuation, Total investors, Investors, News

Investors

Each record includes

Name, Type, Date of entry, Rounds participated, Website

Funding detail is available on the Subscription and Enterprise plan.Contact sales →

M&A

Each record includes

Name, Acquisition type, Announced date, Completed date, Status, Website, News

Investment

Each record includes

Name, Round, Announced date, Lead investor, Website, News

M&A and investment is available on the Subscription and Enterprise plan.Contact sales →

Test Valley Borough Council

Local Government Servicestestvalley.gov.uk

Test Valley Borough Council is a statutory UK local government authority serving residents and businesses of the Test Valley borough in Hampshire. It delivers mandated services including waste management, planning, housing, parking, licensing, benefits administration, and community facilities.

What Test Valley Borough Council does

Test Valley Borough Council is a statutory UK local government authority serving the Test Valley borough in Hampshire, England, encompassing the towns of Andover and Romsey and surrounding villages. The council delivers a comprehensive portfolio of mandated public services to borough residents and businesses, including waste collection and recycling, street cleaning, planning and building control, housing and homelessness services, council tax and benefits administration, licensing and regulation, parking management, and community leisure facilities such as parks, allotments, and The Lights cultural venue.

The council's technology footprint is modest and typical of UK district councils. Its primary digital surface is the public-facing website at testvalley.gov.uk, supplemented by the My Test Valley online self-service portal (my.testvalley.gov.uk), through which residents can report issues, submit service requests, and transact 24/7. The website is partially WCAG 2.1 AA compliant with adjustable text-size and contrast settings. No proprietary platform, custom AI/ML system, or significant technology IP was identified in the source material. Outreach is conducted via Facebook, Twitter/X, a GovDelivery email newsletter, and community engagement initiatives such as Sparkle Days and the Love Where You Live environmental programme (with roughly 950 registered Community Litter Picker households).

The council's revenue model is consistent with UK local authority funding. It is primarily financed through council tax, retained business rates, and central government grants, with a supplemental fee stream from published annual fees and charges covering planning, parking, licensing, waste, and facility rentals. Service delivery spans two physical council offices (Andover headquarters at Beech Hurst and a Romsey office), the digital self-service portal, telephone and email contact centres, and field operations. The council is governed by elected councillors with operational oversight from a professional management team. The source material references an ongoing local government reorganisation initiative, indicating potential structural changes to the council's governance arrangements.

Test Valley Borough Council firmographics

Firmographics
Name
Test Valley Borough Council
Legal name
Test Valley Borough Council
Website
https://testvalley.gov.uk
Company type
Public
Operating status
Operating
Headcount range
251–500 employees
Short description
Test Valley Borough Council is a statutory UK local government authority serving residents and businesses of the Test Valley borough in Hampshire. It delivers mandated services including waste management, planning, housing, parking, licensing, benefits administration, and community facilities.
Ownership category
akta.pro rank

Test Valley Borough Council industry classification

Industry
Product category
Local Government Services
NAICS
Administration of Environmental Quality Programs (9241), Administration of Housing Programs, Urban Planning, and Community Development (925), Administration of Housing Programs, Urban Planning, and Community Development (9251)
SIC
Sanitary Services (4950), Refuse Systems (4953), Services-Social Services (8300)
akta.pro industry
PRIMARYBPAIACAD
Municipal Tax & Revenue Administration (Local)

Keywords

  • Local government services
  • Waste management services
  • Planning and building control
  • Council tax administration
  • Parking and transport

Where Test Valley Borough Council is headquartered

Location

Headquarters

HQ city
Andover
HQ country
United Kingdom
HQ region
Europe

Offices2 records

Markets served

Test Valley Borough Council business model

Business model
GTM type
B2C
Offering type
Services
Cost components
Personnel, Operations, Infrastructure, Technology or R&D, Others

Pricing tiers

ModelBillingPrice
OtherAnnualFees and Charges 2026-27

Distribution channels3 records

Marketing channels5 records

Test Valley Borough Council product offering

Product offering

Core offering

Test Valley Borough Council is a statutory local government authority that delivers mandated public services to residents and businesses in the Test Valley area of Hampshire, England. Its core offerings include waste collection and recycling, planning and building control, housing services, council tax and benefits administration, parking management, licensing and regulation, street cleaning, and community leisure facilities. Services are funded through council tax, business rates, and central government grants, and are delivered through two council offices in Andover and Romsey, the public website, and the My Test Valley online self-service portal.

Product overview

Test Valley Borough Council provides a comprehensive portfolio of local government services to residents and businesses in the Test Valley area of Hampshire. The council operates as a service provider across multiple domains including waste management and recycling, parking and car parks, street cleaning, planning services, benefits administration, housing, licensing, and community leisure facilities. Services are delivered through a combination of physical locations (two council offices in Andover and Romsey), online self-service portals (My Test Valley), and direct service operations. The council's digital presence includes website-based information and transaction services, with some forms built and hosted through third-party software.

Differentiator

Problem solved

Functional benefit

Products and services

  • Waste & Recycling Services Municipal waste collection, recycling programs, household waste recycling centres, home composting support, and hazardous waste disposal services for residents within the Test Valley borough.
  • Parking & Car Parks Management of public car parks in Andover and Romsey, parking permits, penalty charge notices, RingGo mobile payment, electric vehicle charging, and Blue Badge concessions.
  • Street Cleaning & Litter Services Street sweeping, litter removal, leaf clearance, dog waste bin management, graffiti removal coordination, community litter picker programmes, and fly-tipping investigation and enforcement.
  • Planning Services Development management, planning policy, building control, heritage protection, archaeology reviews, and neighbourhood planning for the borough.
  • Benefits & Council Tax Administration of local council tax, housing benefits, business rates, and related financial services for residents and businesses.
  • Housing Services Affordable housing, housing applications, homelessness assistance, and private sector housing support.
  • Licensing Services Animal welfare licensing, zoo licensing, street trading consents, and other regulatory licensing under the Zoo Licensing Act 1981.
  • Community & Leisure Parks and green spaces, allotments, markets in Andover, The Lights venue, community safety initiatives, and antisocial behaviour coordination.
  • Online Reporting & Self-Service Portal (My Test Valley) Online portal for residents to report issues, access services, submit requests, and manage council-related transactions digitally.

Quantifiable outcome

  • Community Litter Pickers programme: ~950 households registered throughout the borough
  • +3 more outcomes

Companies that use Test Valley Borough Council

Customer profile

Segments1 record

Ideal customer profiles2 records

Test Valley Borough Council technology and API

Technology

Technology focussed No

API detail

Has API
No
API docs
API detail

Core technology

AI maturity

App detail

Test Valley Borough Council partnerships and signals

Strategic signal

Partnerships

Six partnerships are on record, tiered core and minor.

  • Hampshire County CouncilcoreStrategic or Co-development PartnerHampshire County Council is a key partner responsible for Household Waste Recycling Centres (HWRCs), highways maintenance, on-street parking enforcement, and community transport (Connect) within the Test Valley area. The two councils collaborate on travel planning through My Journey Hampshire and share data for the National Fraud Initiative. HWRCs in Test Valley include Scott Close (Andover) and Casbrook/Bunny Lane (near Romsey).
  • The LightsminorStrategic or Co-development PartnerThe Lights is a cultural venue and arts centre in Andover that Test Valley Borough Council partners with for events programming. The council website links to The Lights event listings, indicating a collaborative relationship for cultural and community event promotion.
  • Community PaybackminorStrategic or Co-development PartnerTest Valley Borough Council works in partnership with Community Payback, a rehabilitative community service programme, to assist with litter picking, hedge cutting, re-painting, and repairs throughout the borough.
  • Cabinet OfficecoreStrategic or Co-development PartnerTest Valley Borough Council participates in the Cabinet Office's National Fraud Initiative, a data matching exercise to assist in the prevention and detection of fraud. The council provides particular sets of data to the Minister for the Cabinet Office for matching under statutory authority (Part 6 of the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014).
  • Project IntegraminorStrategic or Co-development PartnerProject Integra is referenced as a partner for household waste recycling centre information, suggesting a waste management partnership among Hampshire local authorities coordinated through this initiative.
  • My Journey HampshireminorChannel Partner/ Reseller/ DistributorMy Journey Hampshire is a travel awareness campaign delivered by local councils including Test Valley Borough Council, with funding from the Department for Transport. It provides travel information and advice across the Hampshire area including walking, cycling, bus, train, and car travel options.

Recent moves6 records

Expansion highlights4 records

Test Valley Borough Council competitors and assessment

Company assessment

Direct peers

  • Winchester City Council: Adjacent Hampshire district council serving a comparable mix of town and rural residents with the same statutory service portfolio; useful peer for benchmarking service quality and digital delivery.
  • Chichester District Council: Another southern English district council with a comparable rural-urban mix and statutory service portfolio; useful peer for digital channel and community programme benchmarks.
  • New Forest District Council: Adjacent Hampshire district with similar semi-rural geography and resident base, delivering identical statutory functions; directly comparable on service scope and digital maturity.
  • Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council: Larger Hampshire neighbour providing the same statutory services, with overlapping residents and shared Hampshire-wide initiatives; a natural peer for operational comparison.
  • Surrey Heath Borough Council: Mid-sized southern English district council delivering the same statutory services with a comparable resident base; useful peer for benchmarking fees, charges, and digital portal uptake.
  • Eastleigh Borough Council: Neighbouring Hampshire district council delivering the same statutory services (waste, planning, housing, licensing) to a similar suburban/semi-rural population. Closest like-for-like comparator.

Others

  • Project Integra: Hampshire-wide waste partnership of which Test Valley is a member; comparable as an ecosystem partner rather than a competitor, relevant for understanding waste service economics.

Broad incumbents

  • Wiltshire Council: Unitary authority neighbouring Hampshire with overlapping residents in the Salisbury/Test Valley corridor; comparable on waste and planning but operating at a larger unit scale.
  • Hampshire County Council: Upper-tier authority that delivers county-wide services (highways, HWRCs, on-street parking) overlapping with Test Valley's footprint. Direct strategic partner and the most operationally comparable peer.

Regional players

  • Salisbury City Council: Parish-level council just across the Wiltshire border serving the Salisbury catchment that overlaps parts of Test Valley; comparable on community engagement and local service delivery.

Market position

Strengths4 records

Weaknesses4 records

Competitive moat2 records

Key risks4 records

Key highlights6 records

Customer concentration

Test Valley Borough Council social profiles

Digital presence

Test Valley Borough Council financial estimates

Financial estimate

Revenue estimate

Valuation estimate

Test Valley Borough Council leadership team

Management profile

Number of profiles

Test Valley Borough Council funding detail

Funding detail

Funding overview

Funding rounds

Investors

Funding detail is available on the Subscription and Enterprise plan.Contact sales →

Test Valley Borough Council M&A and investment

M&A and investment

M&A

Investments

M&A and investment is available on the Subscription and Enterprise plan.Contact sales →

Frequently asked questions about Test Valley Borough Council

What does Test Valley Borough Council do?

Test Valley Borough Council is a statutory local government authority that delivers mandated public services to residents and businesses in the Test Valley area of Hampshire, England. Its core offerings include waste collection and recycling, planning and building control, housing services, council tax and benefits administration, parking management, licensing and regulation, street cleaning, and community leisure facilities. Services are funded through council tax, business rates, and central government grants, and are delivered through two council offices in Andover and Romsey, the public website, and the My Test Valley online self-service portal.

Is Test Valley Borough Council a public or private company?

Test Valley Borough Council is a public company. It is classified as state government owned and is currently operating.

When was Test Valley Borough Council founded?

Test Valley Borough Council was founded in -1. It employs 251 to 500 people.

Where is Test Valley Borough Council based?

Test Valley Borough Council is headquartered in Andover, United Kingdom, in the Europe region.

Who are Test Valley Borough Council's main competitors?

Direct peers on record are Winchester City Council, Chichester District Council, New Forest District Council, Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council, Surrey Heath Borough Council and Eastleigh Borough Council. Project Integra is listed as an others. Broad incumbents are Wiltshire Council and Hampshire County Council. Salisbury City Council is listed as a regional player.

Does Test Valley Borough Council have an API?

No public API is recorded for Test Valley Borough Council.

What industry is Test Valley Borough Council in?

Test Valley Borough Council's product category is Local Government Services. Its primary akta.pro industry code is BPAIACAD, Municipal Tax & Revenue Administration (Local). Its NAICS code is 9241 and its SIC code is 4950.

Unlock the full company data

50 free credits on sign-up, no credit card required.

Contact sales
Live signals
EIN PresswireFood waste scheme cuts Test Valley household waste by 18 per centTest Valley Borough Council's food waste recycling scheme cut household waste by 18% since October 2025. Residents recycled about 4,000 tonnes, averaging 345 tonnes monthly, with waste processed via anaerobic digestion for biogas and fertiliser.EIN PresswireDeveloper delight over approval for 190 homes approved in Test ValleyTest Valley Borough Council approved Persimmon Homes' outline plan for 190 zero-carbon-ready homes at Packridge Farm, North Baddesley, with over half the site retained as green space. The scheme includes 76 affordable homes and developer contributions of nearly £370,000 to local facilities and £2.5 million for infrastructure.Premier Construction NewsTest Valley Borough Council partners with Stannah Lifts to enhance passenger safety and lift reliability -Test Valley Borough Council partnered with Stannah Lifts to provide lift maintenance across 6 sites, including Chantry Centre and public car parks. The council selected Stannah for its regional engineer coverage and 24/7 support, covering passenger, platform, and goods lifts from multiple manufacturers.BloombergWe Grant Personhood to Companies. Why Not to Nature?UK councils have granted rivers legal personhood, including Test Valley Borough Council's July vote and Lewes District Council's support for a river charter. The article notes the movement's momentum, citing New Zealand's Whanganui River and Colombia, Canada, and Bangladesh, while also citing critics like Noah Sachs who call the rights vague.