Developer docs
API playgroundTry for free, no card

Search company profiles

Retail Energy Advancement League

Full company profile

uuid0057jo9

Namestring
Retail Energy Advancement League
Legal namestring
Retail Energy Advancement League
Company typeenum
Private
Founded yearint
2022
Descriptiontext

Retail Energy Advancement League (REAL) is a Washington, DC-area nonprofit trade association founded in 2022 to advocate for the expansion and modernization of U.S. retail energy markets. Its mission is to advance "energy choice" legislation that allows residential and commercial consumers to select competitive electricity and gas suppliers rather than be served exclusively by incumbent utility monopolies. REAL operates as a coalition of eight disclosed enterprise member companies — Calpine, CleanChoice Energy, Constellation, Genie Retail Energy, IGS, NRG Energy, Shell Energy, and Vistra Corp — and is funded through membership dues on a recurring basis.

The organization does not develop or sell technology products. Its core deliverables are advocacy services: legislative engagement at the state level, grassroots coalition building, consumer education through a website, state-specific shopping guides, monthly state product summaries, and email/social media campaigns. REAL has demonstrated legal capability through outside counsel (Wiley Rein LLP, McDowell Hetherington), notably securing a First Amendment preliminary injunction against Maryland SB1 in the Fourth Circuit, and is actively pursuing retail-choice legislation in additional states such as Missouri. It also partners with think tanks (R Street Institute) and free-market advocacy groups (Americans for Prosperity-Missouri) to amplify its reach beyond a six-person staff.

Short descriptiontext

The Retail Energy Advancement League is a 2022-founded, Arlington, VA-based nonprofit trade association that advocates for U.S. retail energy choice legislation on behalf of a coalition of major electricity and gas suppliers serving residential and commercial consumers.

Operating statusenum
Operating
Ownership categoryenum
Headcount rangeband
1–10
akta.pro rankint
HeadquartersArlington, United States
HQ citystring
Arlington
HQ countrystring
United States
HQ regionstring
North America
Markets served

Serves global market

Offices1 record

Each record includes

City, Country, Type, Description, Source

Keyword5 values
energy market advocacy, retail energy competition, consumer energy choice, energy policy lobbying, competitive energy markets
Industry2 codes
1Competitive Retail Electricity Supply (Residential & SMB)
CodeEUAGABABPrimaryYes
2Retail Supply & Corporate Energy Procurement (Green Tariffs, Retail PPAs, C&I Supply)
CodeEUAMAMAMPrimaryNo
Product category
Energy Policy Advocacy
GTM motion1 record

Each record includes

Type, Description, Source

Revenue model1 record
1Membership dues
TypeSubscription Recurring
Description

REAL is comprised of retail energy companies that pay membership dues. The organization is funded by member companies dedicated to the expansion and modernization of American retail energy markets.

retailenergychoice.org
Marketing channels6 records

Each record includes

Title, Type, Stage, Description, Source

Distribution channels1 record

Each record includes

Title, Type, Scope, Target buyer, Description, Source

Cost components4 values
Personnel, Operations, Others, Marketing or Sales
GTM typeB2B
B2B
Offering typeServices
Services
Core offering1 text field

Retail Energy Advancement League is a nonprofit trade association that advocates for competitive retail electricity and natural gas markets. Its core activities include legislative and regulatory advocacy, legal litigation in defense of consumer energy choice, and the production of consumer education tools such as state-by-state shopping guides and monthly state product summaries for retail energy offerings.

Differentiator
Functional benefit
Problem solved
Quantifiable outcome1 of 7 values shown
  • Consumer savings of $1.5 billion+ in Massachusetts since restructuring
+6 more records
Product overview1 text field

Retail Energy Advancement League (REAL) is a national advocacy organization dedicated to the expansion and modernization of American retail energy markets, not a product or technology company. The organization provides advocacy services, consumer education resources, and market intelligence including state shopping guides, monthly state product summaries, and legislative advocacy for competitive energy markets. The organization is comprised of retail energy company members and does not offer commercial products or services.

Scale indicator7 records

Each record includes

Type, Value, Description, Source

Partnership15 partners
Strategic tierCoreTypeImplementation/ SI/ Consulting PartnerAnnounced on2024-10-01
Description

Legal counsel representing REAL in litigation against Maryland's Senate Bill 1. Successfully secured a preliminary injunction and won a First Amendment victory in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.

Strategic tierCoreTypeOthers
Description

Member company of REAL. Calpine is a major retail energy supplier and power generation company. The company participates in advocacy efforts to expand competitive energy markets and consumer choice.

Strategic tierCoreTypeOthers
Description

Member company of REAL. CleanChoice Energy offers 100% renewable energy products to residential customers and actively participates in REAL's advocacy for consumer access to clean energy options.

Strategic tierCoreTypeOthers
Description

Member company of REAL. Constellation is a leading retail energy supplier serving residential, commercial, and industrial customers across multiple states.

Strategic tierCoreTypeOthers
Description

Member company of REAL. Genie Retail Energy is a retail energy supplier focused on providing competitive energy options to consumers.

6IGS
Strategic tierCoreTypeOthers
Description

Member company of REAL. IGS is a retail energy supplier offering competitive electricity and natural gas options to customers in regulated states.

retailenergychoice.org
Strategic tierCoreTypeOthers
Description

Member company of REAL. NRG Energy is a major retail energy supplier and power generation company actively involved in advocacy for competitive energy markets.

Strategic tierCoreTypeOthers
Description

Member company of REAL. Shell Energy is the retail energy arm of Shell offering electricity and natural gas to commercial and residential customers in competitive markets.

Strategic tierCoreTypeOthers
Description

Member company of REAL. Vistra Corp is a large retail energy company providing electricity and related services to customers across the United States.

Strategic tierSupportingTypeImplementation/ SI/ Consulting Partner
Description

Law firm partner providing legal expertise in retail energy matters. REAL conducted a Q&A interview with the firm highlighting their experience in energy sector litigation.

Strategic tierSupportingTypeGTM or Marketing Partner
Description

Advocacy partner participating in Missouri energy reform efforts. Provides consumer education and outreach support for energy choice legislation.

Strategic tierSupportingTypeGTM or Marketing Partner
Description

Free-market advocacy organization partnering with REAL on Missouri energy reform. Provides grassroots advocacy and coalition support for competitive energy market legislation.

13Missouri Industrial Energy Consumers
Strategic tierSupportingTypeGTM or Marketing Partner
Description

Trade association representing large industrial energy users in Missouri. Testified in favor of Senate Bill 1411 and advocates for competitive energy markets.

retailenergychoice.org
Strategic tierCoreTypeStrategic or Co-development Partner
Description

Public policy think tank that developed the State-by-State Scorecard on Electricity Competition. REAL endorses and promotes this grading report as a valuable resource for state leaders to improve energy markets.

15Frank Lacey / Electric Advisors Consulting
Strategic tierSupportingTypeOthers
Description

Independent energy markets consultant who authored guest blog posts for REAL on EV charging markets and competitive market issues.

retailenergychoice.org
Recent move6 records

Each record includes

Date, Type, Title, Description, Source

Expansion highlight5 records

Each record includes

Type, Description

Peers10 records
TypeDirect peer
Description

ACORE is a nonprofit trade association focused on renewable energy market development. It is comparable to REAL in advocating for renewable energy market access and competitive structures, and shares membership overlap with some REAL member companies like Calpine and Constellation.

TypeBroad incumbent
Description

AGA is the trade association representing natural gas utilities and transmission companies. It is comparable as an industry trade association with parallel legislative and regulatory advocacy function in the retail energy market, though positioned differently on the competitive-vs-monopoly spectrum.

TypeBroad incumbent
Description

NRECA is the trade association representing rural electric cooperatives. It is comparable as a utility trade association engaged in federal and state energy policy advocacy, particularly on retail market structure and competitive access for cooperative-served territories.

TypeEmerging player
Description

Americans for Prosperity is a free-market advocacy organization that has partnered with REAL on Missouri energy reform. It is comparable as a grassroots coalition ally aligned on retail energy choice advocacy and consumer freedom in energy markets.

TypeOthers
Description

NRDC is a major environmental advocacy organization active in energy policy, including competitive renewable energy markets. It is comparable as a non-corporate advocacy organization influencing retail energy market structure and renewable product policy, though typically aligned with different policy mechanisms than REAL.

TypeBroad incumbent
Description

APPA represents community-owned, not-for-profit electric utilities. It is comparable as a utility-sector trade association engaged in policy advocacy on retail market structure, and would be a counter-position in debates over expanding customer choice.

TypeEmerging player
Description

R Street is a free-market think tank that has partnered with REAL to develop the State-by-State Scorecard on Electricity Competition. It is comparable as a policy-aligned advocacy partner with shared pro-competition energy positions and a track record of state-level policy research.

TypeBroad incumbent
Description

EEI is the trade association representing U.S. investor-owned electric utilities. It is comparable as the policy counter-position to REAL — the principal industry lobbying force on the opposite side of the competitive-versus-monopoly debate — making it the most strategically relevant counterpart organization.

TypeDirect peer
Description

SEIA is the national trade association for the U.S. solar industry. It is comparable as a parallel industry coalition advocating for renewable energy market access and against utility restrictions, and overlaps with REAL's renewable marketing advocacy agenda.

TypeDirect peer
Description

Consumer Energy Alliance is a nonprofit advocacy organization promoting consumer access to affordable, reliable energy, including competitive retail energy markets. It is comparable to REAL in mission, structure, and advocacy focus, operating as a coalition of energy stakeholders supporting energy choice.

Market position
Strengths4 records

Each record includes

Headline, Details, Source

Weaknesses5 records

Each record includes

Headline, Details, Source

Competitive moat4 records

Each record includes

Type, Details

Key risks6 records

Each record includes

Headline, Details, Source

Key highlights6 records

Each record includes

Headline, Details, Source

Customer concentration

Classification, Details

Named customers8 records

Each record includes

Name, Industry, Type, Use case, Source, UUID

Segment3 records

Each record includes

Title, Type, Primary, Description, Pain point addressed, Use case, Source

Ideal customer profile2 records

Each record includes

Profile, Firmographic size, Sales motion, Sales cycle length, Buying structure, Purchase trigger, Buyer persona, Geography, Industry vertical, Primary use case, Description, Pain points, Evidence proof points, Target buyer

Technology focused
No
API detail
Has APIbool
No

Docs URL, Description

AI maturity
App detail

Has app

Core technology
Revenue estimate
Valuation estimate
Number of profiles
Profiles1 record

Each record includes

Name, Designation, Designation category, Overview, Profile commentary, Source

No data
No data
Funding overview

Funding stage, Last funding date, Total funding USD

Funding rounds

Each record includes

Round, Amount USD, Date, Pre money valuation, Total investors, Investors, News

Investors

Each record includes

Name, Type, Date of entry, Rounds participated, Website

Funding detail is available on the Subscription and Enterprise plan.Contact sales →

M&A

Each record includes

Name, Acquisition type, Announced date, Completed date, Status, Website, News

Investment

Each record includes

Name, Round, Announced date, Lead investor, Website, News

M&A and investment is available on the Subscription and Enterprise plan.Contact sales →

Retail Energy Advancement League

Energy Policy Advocacyretailenergychoice.org

The Retail Energy Advancement League is a 2022-founded, Arlington, VA-based nonprofit trade association that advocates for U.S. retail energy choice legislation on behalf of a coalition of major electricity and gas suppliers serving residential and commercial consumers.

What Retail Energy Advancement League does

Retail Energy Advancement League (REAL) is a Washington, DC-area nonprofit trade association founded in 2022 to advocate for the expansion and modernization of U.S. retail energy markets. Its mission is to advance "energy choice" legislation that allows residential and commercial consumers to select competitive electricity and gas suppliers rather than be served exclusively by incumbent utility monopolies. REAL operates as a coalition of eight disclosed enterprise member companies — Calpine, CleanChoice Energy, Constellation, Genie Retail Energy, IGS, NRG Energy, Shell Energy, and Vistra Corp — and is funded through membership dues on a recurring basis.

The organization does not develop or sell technology products. Its core deliverables are advocacy services: legislative engagement at the state level, grassroots coalition building, consumer education through a website, state-specific shopping guides, monthly state product summaries, and email/social media campaigns. REAL has demonstrated legal capability through outside counsel (Wiley Rein LLP, McDowell Hetherington), notably securing a First Amendment preliminary injunction against Maryland SB1 in the Fourth Circuit, and is actively pursuing retail-choice legislation in additional states such as Missouri. It also partners with think tanks (R Street Institute) and free-market advocacy groups (Americans for Prosperity-Missouri) to amplify its reach beyond a six-person staff.

Retail Energy Advancement League firmographics

Firmographics
Name
Retail Energy Advancement League
Legal name
Retail Energy Advancement League
Website
https://retailenergychoice.org
Company type
Private
Founded year
2022
Operating status
Operating
Headcount range
1–10 employees
Short description
The Retail Energy Advancement League is a 2022-founded, Arlington, VA-based nonprofit trade association that advocates for U.S. retail energy choice legislation on behalf of a coalition of major electricity and gas suppliers serving residential and commercial consumers.
Ownership category
akta.pro rank

Retail Energy Advancement League industry classification

Industry
Product category
Energy Policy Advocacy
akta.pro primary industry
Competitive Retail Electricity Supply (Residential & SMB) (EUAGABAB)
akta.pro secondary industry
Retail Supply & Corporate Energy Procurement (Green Tariffs, Retail PPAs, C&I Supply) (EUAMAMAM)

Keywords

  • Energy market advocacy
  • Retail energy competition
  • Consumer energy choice
  • Energy policy lobbying
  • Competitive energy markets

Where Retail Energy Advancement League is headquartered

Location

Headquarters

HQ city
Arlington
HQ country
United States
HQ region
North America

Offices1 record

Markets served

Retail Energy Advancement League business model

Business model
GTM type
B2B
Offering type
Services
Cost components
Personnel, Operations, Others, Marketing or Sales

Revenue model

  1. Membership dues: REAL is comprised of retail energy companies that pay membership dues. The organization is funded by member companies dedicated to the expansion and modernization of American retail energy markets.

Go-to-market motion1 record

Distribution channels1 record

Marketing channels6 records

Retail Energy Advancement League product offering

Product offering

Core offering

Retail Energy Advancement League is a nonprofit trade association that advocates for competitive retail electricity and natural gas markets. Its core activities include legislative and regulatory advocacy, legal litigation in defense of consumer energy choice, and the production of consumer education tools such as state-by-state shopping guides and monthly state product summaries for retail energy offerings.

Product overview

Retail Energy Advancement League (REAL) is a national advocacy organization dedicated to the expansion and modernization of American retail energy markets, not a product or technology company. The organization provides advocacy services, consumer education resources, and market intelligence including state shopping guides, monthly state product summaries, and legislative advocacy for competitive energy markets. The organization is comprised of retail energy company members and does not offer commercial products or services.

Differentiator

Problem solved

Functional benefit

Quantifiable outcome

  • Consumer savings of $1.5 billion+ in Massachusetts since restructuring
  • +6 more outcomes

Companies that use Retail Energy Advancement League

Customer profile

Named customers8 records

Segments3 records

Ideal customer profiles2 records

Retail Energy Advancement League technology and API

Technology

Technology focussed No

API detail

Has API
No
API docs
API detail

Core technology

AI maturity

App detail

Retail Energy Advancement League partnerships and signals

Strategic signal

Partnerships

15 partnerships are on record, tiered core and supporting.

  • Wiley Rein LLPcoreImplementation/ SI/ Consulting Partner · 1 October 2024Legal counsel representing REAL in litigation against Maryland's Senate Bill 1. Successfully secured a preliminary injunction and won a First Amendment victory in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.
  • CalpinecoreOthersMember company of REAL. Calpine is a major retail energy supplier and power generation company. The company participates in advocacy efforts to expand competitive energy markets and consumer choice.
  • CleanChoice EnergycoreOthersMember company of REAL. CleanChoice Energy offers 100% renewable energy products to residential customers and actively participates in REAL's advocacy for consumer access to clean energy options.
  • ConstellationcoreOthersMember company of REAL. Constellation is a leading retail energy supplier serving residential, commercial, and industrial customers across multiple states.
  • Genie Retail EnergycoreOthersMember company of REAL. Genie Retail Energy is a retail energy supplier focused on providing competitive energy options to consumers.
  • IGScoreOthersMember company of REAL. IGS is a retail energy supplier offering competitive electricity and natural gas options to customers in regulated states.
  • NRG EnergycoreOthersMember company of REAL. NRG Energy is a major retail energy supplier and power generation company actively involved in advocacy for competitive energy markets.
  • Shell EnergycoreOthersMember company of REAL. Shell Energy is the retail energy arm of Shell offering electricity and natural gas to commercial and residential customers in competitive markets.
  • Vistra CorpcoreOthersMember company of REAL. Vistra Corp is a large retail energy company providing electricity and related services to customers across the United States.
  • McDowell HetheringtonsupportingImplementation/ SI/ Consulting PartnerLaw firm partner providing legal expertise in retail energy matters. REAL conducted a Q&A interview with the firm highlighting their experience in energy sector litigation.
  • My Energy ChoicesupportingGTM or Marketing PartnerAdvocacy partner participating in Missouri energy reform efforts. Provides consumer education and outreach support for energy choice legislation.
  • Americans for Prosperity-MissourisupportingGTM or Marketing PartnerFree-market advocacy organization partnering with REAL on Missouri energy reform. Provides grassroots advocacy and coalition support for competitive energy market legislation.
  • Missouri Industrial Energy ConsumerssupportingGTM or Marketing PartnerTrade association representing large industrial energy users in Missouri. Testified in favor of Senate Bill 1411 and advocates for competitive energy markets.
  • R Street InstitutecoreStrategic or Co-development PartnerPublic policy think tank that developed the State-by-State Scorecard on Electricity Competition. REAL endorses and promotes this grading report as a valuable resource for state leaders to improve energy markets.
  • Frank Lacey / Electric Advisors ConsultingsupportingOthersIndependent energy markets consultant who authored guest blog posts for REAL on EV charging markets and competitive market issues.

Scale indicators7 records

Recent moves6 records

Expansion highlights5 records

Retail Energy Advancement League competitors and assessment

Company assessment

Direct peers

  • American Council on Renewable Energy: ACORE is a nonprofit trade association focused on renewable energy market development. It is comparable to REAL in advocating for renewable energy market access and competitive structures, and shares membership overlap with some REAL member companies like Calpine and Constellation.
  • Solar Energy Industries Association: SEIA is the national trade association for the U.S. solar industry. It is comparable as a parallel industry coalition advocating for renewable energy market access and against utility restrictions, and overlaps with REAL's renewable marketing advocacy agenda.
  • Consumer Energy Alliance: Consumer Energy Alliance is a nonprofit advocacy organization promoting consumer access to affordable, reliable energy, including competitive retail energy markets. It is comparable to REAL in mission, structure, and advocacy focus, operating as a coalition of energy stakeholders supporting energy choice.

Broad incumbents

  • American Gas Association: AGA is the trade association representing natural gas utilities and transmission companies. It is comparable as an industry trade association with parallel legislative and regulatory advocacy function in the retail energy market, though positioned differently on the competitive-vs-monopoly spectrum.
  • National Rural Electric Cooperative Association: NRECA is the trade association representing rural electric cooperatives. It is comparable as a utility trade association engaged in federal and state energy policy advocacy, particularly on retail market structure and competitive access for cooperative-served territories.
  • American Public Power Association: APPA represents community-owned, not-for-profit electric utilities. It is comparable as a utility-sector trade association engaged in policy advocacy on retail market structure, and would be a counter-position in debates over expanding customer choice.
  • Edison Electric Institute: EEI is the trade association representing U.S. investor-owned electric utilities. It is comparable as the policy counter-position to REAL — the principal industry lobbying force on the opposite side of the competitive-versus-monopoly debate — making it the most strategically relevant counterpart organization.

Emerging players

  • Americans for Prosperity: Americans for Prosperity is a free-market advocacy organization that has partnered with REAL on Missouri energy reform. It is comparable as a grassroots coalition ally aligned on retail energy choice advocacy and consumer freedom in energy markets.
  • R Street Institute: R Street is a free-market think tank that has partnered with REAL to develop the State-by-State Scorecard on Electricity Competition. It is comparable as a policy-aligned advocacy partner with shared pro-competition energy positions and a track record of state-level policy research.

Others

  • Natural Resources Defense Council: NRDC is a major environmental advocacy organization active in energy policy, including competitive renewable energy markets. It is comparable as a non-corporate advocacy organization influencing retail energy market structure and renewable product policy, though typically aligned with different policy mechanisms than REAL.

Market position

Strengths4 records

Weaknesses5 records

Competitive moat4 records

Key risks6 records

Key highlights6 records

Customer concentration

Retail Energy Advancement League social profiles

Digital presence

Retail Energy Advancement League financial estimates

Financial estimate

Revenue estimate

Valuation estimate

Retail Energy Advancement League leadership team

Management profile

Number of profiles

Profiles1 record

Retail Energy Advancement League funding detail

Funding detail

Funding overview

Funding rounds

Investors

Funding detail is available on the Subscription and Enterprise plan.Contact sales →

Retail Energy Advancement League M&A and investment

M&A and investment

M&A

Investments

M&A and investment is available on the Subscription and Enterprise plan.Contact sales →

Frequently asked questions about Retail Energy Advancement League

What does Retail Energy Advancement League do?

Retail Energy Advancement League is a nonprofit trade association that advocates for competitive retail electricity and natural gas markets. Its core activities include legislative and regulatory advocacy, legal litigation in defense of consumer energy choice, and the production of consumer education tools such as state-by-state shopping guides and monthly state product summaries for retail energy offerings.

Is Retail Energy Advancement League a public or private company?

Retail Energy Advancement League is a private company. It is classified as nonprofit foundation owned and is currently operating.

When was Retail Energy Advancement League founded?

Retail Energy Advancement League was founded in 2022. It employs 1 to 10 people.

Where is Retail Energy Advancement League based?

Retail Energy Advancement League is headquartered in Arlington, United States, in the North America region.

How does Retail Energy Advancement League make money?

One revenue line is on record: membership dues.

Who are Retail Energy Advancement League's main competitors?

Direct peers on record are American Council on Renewable Energy, Solar Energy Industries Association and Consumer Energy Alliance. Broad incumbents are American Gas Association, National Rural Electric Cooperative Association, American Public Power Association and Edison Electric Institute. Emerging players are Americans for Prosperity and R Street Institute. Natural Resources Defense Council is listed as an others.

Does Retail Energy Advancement League have an API?

No public API is recorded for Retail Energy Advancement League.

What industry is Retail Energy Advancement League in?

Retail Energy Advancement League's product category is Energy Policy Advocacy. Its primary akta.pro industry code is EUAGABAB, Competitive Retail Electricity Supply (Residential & SMB), with a secondary code of EUAMAMAM, Retail Supply & Corporate Energy Procurement (Green Tariffs, Retail PPAs, C&I Supply).

Unlock the full company data

50 free credits on sign-up, no credit card required.

Contact sales
Live signals
The Cool DownMassachusetts electric suppliers spend $80K lobbying against proposed utility restrictionsTwo trade groups representing Massachusetts competitive electric suppliers, the Retail Energy Supply Association and the Retail Energy Advancement League, spent $80,000 lobbying against a bill that would let cities and towns decide whether third-party suppliers can sell electricity directly to residents. At that pace, spending would reach about $160,000, their largest annual total since 2022. The industry also commissioned a poll of 500 ratepayers finding roughly 9 in 10 support keeping supplier choice.RetailenergychoiceRetail Energy Advancement LeagueA coalition of companies known as the Retail Energy Advancement League is advocating for the expansion and modernization of retail energy markets in the U.S. The organization argues that outdated utility monopolies restrict consumer choice and hinder investments in clean energy. It emphasizes the need for smart regulation and consumer protections to facilitate a transition to an affordable and reliable clean energy economy.Bloomberg Law NewsJudges Press Maryland, Energy Coalition Over Green Marketing LawJudges at the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit heard arguments Friday regarding Maryland's new law regulating how energy providers can market green power to consumers. The plaintiffs, Retail Energy Advancement League and Green Mountain Energy Company, are challenging the statute on First Amendment grounds, arguing it unconstitutionally restricts speech by requiring providers to meet the state's definition of 'green power.' The judges questioned whether the law actually achieves its stated goal of making the energy market more transparent for consumers.RetailenergychoiceENERGY CHOICE IN MASSACHUSETTSMassachusetts competitive energy suppliers serve nearly 70% of the state's electric load, offering customers potential savings of up to 31% compared to utility rates. Legislative efforts are currently underway to either close the competitive market or enhance consumer protections and shopping options. The Retail Energy Advancement League (REAL) is actively advocating against proposals that would eliminate consumer choice in favor of utility-only service.